FAQ -Overdesign

Reproduced with acknowledgement to http://www.adventurealan.com/over_design.htm
Send any comments to the maintainer Roger Caffin

There are only a few hardcore climbers and outdoor people that need equipment designed for the extreme environmental conditions and abuse that most outdoor equipment is designed to withstand. The rest of us “hikers” need much lighter equipment designed for the milder environmental conditions and stresses we encounter. So why do manufacturers continue to over-design equipment?

• For warrantee and 100% satisfaction guarantee reasons, most outdoor equipment manufacturers over-design their equipment. They don’t want their products to fail or sully their reputation. Every manufacturer wants their equipment to be referred to as “bombproof.” In their view, no one should come back and say “your sleeping bag isn’t warm enough” or “you used cheap, thin fabric on the shell and it ripped.” Thus, the 3 pound “summer” sleeping bag. It has a heavy shell that is hard to rip, and lots of insulation to keep you very warm. No matter that for around 1.5 pounds you can purchase a summer sleeping bag that will keep you plenty warm, and with proper care last for years.
• Same with backpacks. For around 2 pounds, you can design a perfectly good backpack that will carry up to 40 pounds (about double what some ultralight hikers carry for a week.) Yet some highly rated packs weigh in from 5 to 7+ pounds. These packs tout their ability to carry 50 or more pounds (>23 kg) comfortably. Why would you need or want a pack to carry 50 pounds? Why pay $400 or more for the privilege of carrying an extra 5 pounds?
• In the manufacturer’s defense, there are many novice users who mistreat and abuse equipment. Equipment over-design is the manufacturer’s attempt to protect themselves from these neophytes.
• Outdoor equipment resellers compound the weight problem. They recommend heavy “bombproof” equipment to their clientele. They stay in business with happy customers who have undamaged equipment.
• For liability reasons, retailers also recommend that you buy lots of equipment. Retailers are happy just as long as you are safe.  The more safety products, and backup supplies you buy, the more money they make. The less likely that you’ll encounter problems and accuse of  giving them bad advice.
• Also for liability reasons, if there is any doubt, the retailer will recommend the heavier more supportive hiking boot, the warmer bag, the heavier jacket, that extra piece of clothing, the larger flashlight that puts out more light and lasts longer. I have yet to have any sales staff recommend trail running shoes for day hikes, let alone an extended backpacking trip. I know they’re thinking of the liability if I sprain my ankle, not of my comfort hiking. [Me, I think they are more concerned with the markup - RNC.]